Posts by Edd Doerr

Humanist Voices in Unitarian Universalism: A Book Review

Humanism (with either upper or lower case "h"), whether labelled a philosophy, life stance, worldview, movement or "religion", dates back to the ancient Greece and Rome of Eipicurus and Lucretius.  After lying dormant for centuries it began to reawaken following the Renaissance, the Reformation, the Enlightenment, and the development of science. The Deism of Voltaire and Paine and Jefferson was a sort of proto-humanism. The 19th century growth of democracy, science, public education,  and industry - aided by  Darwin's breakthrough in science - spurred the advances of freethought and rationalism. The Ethical Society movement took off after the Civil War and Unitarian congregations moved leftward theologically toward naturalistic Humanism.

Finally, about 100 years ago some Unitarian ministers and philosophers began using the word "Humanism" to label this movement in religion, culminating in the publication in 1933 of the Humanist Manifesto. Soon after that, Unitarian ministers founded the American Humanist Association, headed for several years by Rev. Edwin Wilson. Years later philosopher Paul Kurtz, the moving force behind the 1973 Humanist Manifesto II, founded the Council for Secular Humanism. By this time a majority of  members of the 1000+ Unitarian Universalist (UU) congregations considered themselves Humanists. Today the largest group of Humanists may be found in UU congregations, while others are in Ethical Societies, Humanistic Jewish congregations, and the two principal Humanist organizations, the Council for Secular Humanism (CSH) and the American Humanist Association (AHA), plus uncountable numbers with no formal affiliation, not to mention the many overseas Humanist organizations in the International Humanist and Ethical Union, founded after World War II.

(Disclosure: I am the author of one of the 24 sections of this book, a signer of Humanist Manifesto II, a friend of Wilson and Kurtz, a columnist in the CSH journal Free Inquiry, a past president of the American Humanist Association, and a long time member of UU congregations.)

Humanist Voices in UUism highlights the great diversity among UUs, among UU Humanists, and among Humanists who are not associated with UU congregations. Of particular importance, the book articulates a Humanism that is positive and affirming and that emphasizes community and social justice.  About half of the authors are UU ministers and half are not. Some Humanists are comfortable with the word "religion" to label their Humanism and some are not. All, I suppose, would agree with my bumpersticker definition of Humanism as a "compassionate ethical naturalism," whether religious or secular.

It should be noted that many UU Humanists have complained that the Humanism that includes about half the members of our congregations, like comic Rodney Dangerfield, often "don't get no respect," from denominational leadership. That needs a fix, as UU Humanism is what largely drove the growth of UUism after World War II.

Further, with the religiously unaffiliated now making up a quarter of the US population and growing, UUism needs Humanism to grow and provide homes for these "nones" and Humanism needs organizations like UU congregations and other groups.

My takeaway from this important book, especially in the wake of the November 2016 electoral disaster, is that Humanists, whether UU or religious or secular, must downplay differences and, working with good people across the religious spectrum, concentrate on dealing with the all too real problems facing our nation and our world (in no particular order): defending our besieged public schools, reproductive choice, civil liberties, voting rights, healthcare advances, religious liberty and church-state separation; coping with the anthropogenic climate change crisis and its concomitants (atmospheric CO2 buildup, environmental degradation, toxic waste accumulation, soil erosion and nutrient loss, biodiversity loss, deforestation,  desertification, sea level rise, and the human overpopulation that fuels climate change.)

Our work is cut out for us.

Edd Doerr Read more about Humanist Voices in Unitarian Universalism: A Book Review »

Categories: 

Book review: Christianity without God, by Daniel C. Maguire

Christianity without God: Moving beyond the Dogmas and Retrieving the Epic Moral Narrative, by Daniel C. Maguire. SUNY Press, 2014, 226 pp, $24.95.

 a review by Edd Doerr

 “In these pages,” Dan Maguire  writes as he begins this important book, “I argue against the existence of a personal god, the divinity of Jesus, and the belief that continued living is the sequel to death. I find no persuasive arguments for any of these hypotheses,” these assumed foundations of Christianity. “What would be refreshing,” he adds, “is a moratorium on god-talk so that together we could explore alternatives to earth’s current social, political, economic, and ecological distress.”

Maguire, Professor of Ethics at (Jesuit) Marquette University and a former priest, is a longtime supporter of women’s rights regarding contraception, abortion and overpopulation. (See my review of his book, Sacred Choices, in Voice of Reason No. 80 in 2002 at arlinc.org.) In this brisk new book, brimming with humor and common sense, Maguire eviscerates the myths and supernaturalism of the Bible and traditional Christian theology but says that there are gems of wisdom and ethics to be found in those sources, though, one cannot help but note, those gems are buried under mountains of muck that require a patient, careful geologist like Maguire to unearth. The book reminds one of the Jefferson Bible or Bernard Shaw’s quip that as his followers did not understand Jesus’ religion, they made him the religion.

Maguire pokes fun at the Vatican’s “pelvic zone orthodoxy” and highlights the importance of dealing with climate change and its concomitants: “deforestation and  habitat destruction, soil erosion and salinization, water management problems, overhunting, overfishing, foreign species affecting native species, human population growth, and increased per capita impact of people,” a litany similar to the one I have long been chanting.  He concludes: “No deity will come to save this gifted and generous earth. It’s a challenge for humans not for gods. . . . The hour is late; some damage is irremediable. But it is not too late to start reversals.”

Further: “We are a spoiled species that seems hell-bent on wrecking the earth that cradles us and we are well on in that demonic suicidal project. It is an alluring temptation for the likes of us to imagine a superbeing with parental passions who is both omnipotent and all merciful who will make everything right ‘on earth as it is in heaven’. Such delusions are typical of adolescence. And adolescent is what we are.”

Maguire’s humanism shines brightly through in this terrific book, though he does not use that term. And it bears out what I wrote in this haiku: “Labels may conceal / far more than they may reveal / they can mask what’s real.” Read more about Book review: Christianity without God, by Daniel C. Maguire »

Categories: